Back to blogs

Electric vs Gas Tankless Water Heater: Which One to Choose?

As the conversation around sustainability gains momentum, so does the transition from traditional water heating solutions to more eco-friendly options. California's Air Resources Board (CARB) has put into place initiatives for a greener future, including measures to phase out gas-powered water heaters by 2030. Being at the forefront of this shift, we understand that homeowners are now facing a pivotal choice: opting for an electric vs gas tankless water heater. In this quest, it's vital to unravel the key differences such as the energy source — with gas tankless water heater vs electric hinging on the use of natural gas or propane, and electric tankless water heater vs gas relying entirely on electricity.

While both systems boast greater efficiency compared to their traditional tank counterparts, heating water only on demand, the type you choose can have significant implications for your home. Whether you lean towards an electric or gas tankless water heater, your decision will reflect on your daily life in terms of convenience, operational cost, and environmental impact. Join us as we delve into the pros and cons of each system, empowering you to make an educated choice for your household's hot water needs.

Key Takeaways

  • Consider the long-term environmental and operational cost implications of choosing between a gas or electric tankless water heater.
  • Keep in mind that the CARB’s initiative serves as a precursor to a shift towards electric tankless water heaters.
  • Recognize that both types of tankless water heaters are markedly more efficient than traditional water heaters with storage tanks.
  • Understand that the choice between electric and gas tankless water heaters hinges not only on energy source differences but also on your household needs and preferences.
  • Ready yourself to weigh the upfront costs alongside the efficiency and flow rate benefits of electric and gas tankless water heaters for an informed decision.

Introduction: The Rise of Tankless Water Heaters

As homeowners become increasingly eco-conscious, the popularity of tankless water heaters is surging. These innovative devices, available as either electric or gas tankless water heaters, embody energy-efficient technology poised to transform the way we use hot water. But when it comes to choosing between the two, many wonder about the difference between electric and gas tankless water heaters and which is better: electric or gas tankless water heater? We're here to guide you through these considerations to ensure you find a water heating solution that aligns with your lifestyle and values.

Unlike traditional models, tankless water heaters deliver hot water on demand and do not store or continuously heat water, significantly reducing energy waste. Both electric and gas tankless water heaters represent leaps forward in terms of efficiency, offering compelling advantages over conventional water heaters. Yet to discern which is supremely suited for your home, assessing the fundamental distinctions between them is crucial. Let's take an exploratory dive into this battle of heating efficiency and convenience and unpack what sets them apart.

Before delving into technical specifications and performance metrics, it's essential to look at the broader landscape. As of September 2022, with CARB's decision to phase out gas-powered water heaters, the contours of this choice are becoming sharper for residents of places like California. The impending restrictions are steering the market and consumer preferences toward electric alternatives, but the question remains, what does this mean for you today?

It's not just about functionality—your choice also reflects your stance on sustainability and energy consumption. With this informative journey into the heart of electric vs gas tankless water heater technologies, we're committed to equipping you with all the necessary data, insights, and expert opinions. Together, we can assess which system not only meets your immediate needs but also supports a greener, more sustainable future for all.

  • We'll explore energy sources and how they influence heater performance
  • Assess installation costs and long-term savings
  • Examine the environmental impact of each heater type
  • Analyze user convenience and service longevity

Join us as we chart the nuances of electric and gas tankless water heaters and help you navigate towards the perfect hot water solution for your home.

The Fundamental Differences in Heating Mechanisms

When assessing the gas tankless water heater vs electric debate, a key area of distinction lies in their respective heating mechanisms. This core functional difference has a significant influence on performance, energy use, and suitability for your home’s hot water requirements. We'll explore the intricacies of how these two types of heaters operate, providing clarity on what sets them apart in the realms of tankless water heating technology.

Understanding the Gas Tankless Heating Process

The heating mechanism of gas tankless water heaters is a marvel of engineering efficiency; however, the process is intricate. Introducing water into the system activates a flow sensor, which then triggers a chain reaction. This sensor signals a gas valve to open, allowing natural gas or propane to flood into a combustion chamber. Once there, an ignition system sparks to life, creating a flame that heats an exchanger. This exchanger, in turn, rapidly warms the passing water to the desired temperature. The intricacies of this process highlight the dynamics behind the energy source's utilization in gas tankless systems.

Deciphering Electric Tankless Water Heater Operations

Delving into how electric tankless water heaters work, the operation may seem simpler. As with gas systems, the journey begins with a flow sensor responding to water movement. This sensor activates a series of metal heating elements, which, once electrified, quickly attain high temperatures. Their heat is directly transferred to the incoming water, circumventing the need for a combustion process. The streamlined efficiency electrical systems offer makes them a standout in the electric tankless water heater vs gas conversation.

  • The immediacy of heat transfer in electric models lends itself to a compact design, often synonymous with lower initial installation complexities.
  • Gas systems’ requirement for a venting solution due to the combustion process may present a constraint in specific installation scenarios.

Feature Gas Tankless Water Heaters Electric Tankless Water Heaters Energy Source Natural gas or propane Electricity Initial Trigger Flow sensor Flow sensor Heat Generation Combustion chamber and flame Electrically heated elements Heat Transfer Through an exchanger Direct to water Venting Required Yes No Installation Complexity Higher due to venting and gas lines Lower, more versatile options

Our exploration of these heating mechanisms underscores not only the differences in electric tankless water heater vs gas models but also their potential suitability for various living environments and needs. In our mission to empower your decision-making, we are committed to bringing these technical details into the light to inform your choice of an efficient, future-ready home heating solution.

Comparing the Upfront Costs: Installation and Units

When homeowners consider upgrading to a tankless water heater, one of the primary concerns is the upfront investment required. We're here to break down the cost comparison electric vs gas tankless water heater for both the unit itself and the associated installation costs of tankless water heaters. By examining these figures, you can better understand what to expect when budgeting for your home's hot water system.

Let’s begin with electric tankless water heaters, which often boast a lower entry price. The cost of the unit alone ranges from $400 to $2,500, depending on the brand and capabilities. Including installation, the price extends to approximately $1,800 to $7,200. Various factors contribute to this spread, such as regional labor rates and the complexity of your home's electrical system.

On the flip side, gas tankless water heaters generally command a higher price for both the unit and installation. You can expect to pay between $1,200 to $2,900 for a robust gas tankless unit. Once installation is factored in, expenses increase to an average of $4,800 to $8,500. The complexity of installing gas lines and ensuring proper ventilation contributes to these higher costs. However, it's essential to weigh these initial expenses against long-term energy savings potential.

  • The capacity of each unit typically influences the cost within these ranges.
  • Professional installation is strongly recommended for both types to ensure safety and efficiency.
  • Working with reputable brands and certified installers can maximize the lifespan and performance of your tankless water heater.

Type Cost of Unit Alone Cost Including Installation Electric Tankless Water Heater $400 - $2,500 $1,800 - $7,200 Gas Tankless Water Heater $1,200 - $2,900 $4,800 - $8,500

We recommend homeowners not to overlook potential savings from energy efficiency which may offset the installation costs over time. While gas units are typically more costly upfront, they may offer more hot water output, suiting homes with greater demand. Conversely, electric units can be ideal for homes with less frequent hot water use or where gas supply is an issue. In summary, choosing between an electric and gas tankless water heater should be an informed decision weighed against both upfront costs and long-term value.

Evaluating Energy Efficiency: Which Saves More Long-Term?

For homeowners eyeing long-term savings, the initial cost is not the only factor worth consideration. The energy efficiency of electric tankless water heaters and the energy performance of gas tankless water heaters play pivotal roles. These factors not only impact the carbon footprint but also translate to economic savings over the duration of the heater's life.

The Efficiency Metrics of Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Success in the realm of energy conservation can be primarily attributed to the efficiency of the water heaters. Electric tankless water heaters stand out with an impressive Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) rating of 0.96 or higher. This high rating showcases their superior energy efficiency, a clear nod to their ability to minimize wasteful energy expenditure while maximizing output.

Energy Efficiency of Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Particularly, households facing fluctuating electricity rates could still find electric tankless heaters a cost-effective choice due to their lean energy usage. Thus, the savvier move could be opting for these electric models, even in regions where electricity may come at a premium price.

Gas Tankless Water Heaters and Their Energy Performance

On the rival end, gas tankless water heaters possess a somewhat lower UEF rating than electric models, which falls between 0.81 and 0.96. While this indicates a lower energy performance comparatively, it is still a leap beyond traditional tank heaters. Factors such as local gas prices can heavily influence operational costs and efficiency outcomes for these gas units. In areas where natural gas prices are stable or lower, these heaters could edge out their electric counterparts in terms of efficiency savings.

  • Electric tankless heaters are top performers in efficiency yet sensitive to high electricity cost regions.
  • Gas tankless heaters' efficiency can be more favorable where gas is a cheaper utility.

Water Heater Type UEF Rating Operational Cost Influencers Electric Tankless Water Heaters 0.96 or higher Electricity rates Gas Tankless Water Heaters 0.81 - 0.96 Gas prices

In assessing these options, one must contemplate the regional cost of utilities and individual preferences for energy sources. Ultimately, aligning one's choice with both monetary and ecological viewpoints leads to a judicious investment—one that recognizes the critical balance between upfront costs and the profound impact of long-term energy savings.

Assessing Water Flow Rates: Who Provides More Hot Water?

When diving into the debate between an electric vs gas tankless water heater, flow rates stand out as a critical area of comparison. This metric is particularly relevant for households trying to determine which system can meet their high demand for hot water. Flow rate, typically measured in gallons per minute (GPM), directly correlates to how many hot water applications can be used simultaneously. It's imperative for us to compare the electric vs gas tankless water heater flow rates to see which might be best suited for your lifestyle.

Gas tankless water heaters usually boast a higher flow rate, delivering between 5 to over 10 GPM. This enables them to supply a larger volume of hot water more rapidly, which can be essential for homes with multiple bathrooms or simultaneous hot water needs. On the other hand, electric tankless water heaters typically offer between 2 to 5 GPM. The reduced flow rate in electric models stems from the limitations inherent in their heating elements, though advancements are expected to enhance this capacity in the future.

Type of Tankless Water Heater Flow Rate (Gallons Per Minute) Electric Tankless Water Heater 2 - 5 GPM Gas Tankless Water Heater 5 - >10 GPM

While we currently see a disparity in flow rates with gas models leading, it's vital to remember that the landscape can and will change. With the prospective phase-out of gas water heaters in states like California, manufacturers are likely to innovate further to increase the flow rates of electric tankless water heaters. For now, we advise homeowners to carefully assess their hot water usage and choose a solution that meets both their immediate and long-term needs.

  • For smaller households or those with lower hot water demands, an electric tankless water heater may suffice.
  • For larger households or homes with higher hot water demands, a gas tankless water heater could be the more appropriate choice, providing more hot water rapidly.
  • As regulations evolve, the technology behind electric tankless water heaters is expected to improve, potentially closing the gap in flow rates between electric and gas models.

Through our analysis of electric vs gas tankless water heater flow rates, we observe current trends that can guide homeowners. It's essential to consider not just the flow rates but also the potential advancements in technology that may influence the hot water supply capabilities of both types of tankless water heaters in the years to come.

Environmental Considerations: Emissions and Greenhouse Gases

As we delve into the environmental impact of electric vs gas tankless water heaters, it's clear that the choice of water heater not only affects our utility bills but also our planet. The tankless water heater emissions play a crucial role in how eco-friendly our homes are, and thus, understanding these impacts is paramount. Let's explore how these two types of heaters differ in their environmental footprint, especially in the context of greenhouse gas emissions.

Electric tankless water heaters are often celebrated for their minimal environmental impact. Unlike their gas-powered counterparts, they do not rely on the combustion of fossil fuels, which means they do not produce greenhouse gases during operation. This is a significant advantage when considering the push towards a more sustainable and environmentally-friendly household. As concerns over climate change intensify, the ability to reduce one's carbon footprint through the use of electric tankless water heaters becomes an attractive proposition.

Conversely, gas tankless water heaters, while more energy-efficient than traditional tank-based water heaters, still contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. This is due to their reliance on natural gas or propane—a fossil fuel that, when combusted, releases carbon dioxide and other emissions into the atmosphere. The impact of these emissions is a critical consideration for homeowners who are evaluating their options with a keen interest in sustainability.

Water Heater Type Greenhouse Gas Emissions Environmental Impact Electric Tankless Water Heater Minimal (No combustion) Reduced carbon footprint Gas Tankless Water Heater Higher (Combustion of fossil fuels) Increased greenhouse effect

  • Electric tankless water heaters are an excellent choice for those looking to minimize their household’s environmental impact.
  • Gas tankless water heaters, though improved from traditional tank models, still pose an environmental concern due to their emissions.

Our commitment to sustainability and environmental protection drives us to consider the broader implications of our product choices. In the efforts to mitigate climate change and reduce household emissions, electric tankless water heaters emerge as a cleaner alternative, reflecting our dedication to eco-friendly living.

Exploring Longevity: Service Life of Electric and Gas Units

When considering the longevity of electric vs gas tankless water heaters, homeowners often seek clarity on the service life comparison between these two types of units. It's a pivotal aspect that informs decisions surrounding investments in household infrastructures. Let's delve into the factors that contribute to the differing lifespans of these tankless water heaters.

Our experience suggests that the relatively simplistic design of electric tankless water heaters is synonymous with durability. These systems forgo the complex mechanisms inherent in their gas counterparts, which can translate to lesser wear and tear over time. In essence, fewer moving parts mean there's less that can go wrong, which naturally extends the unit's operating life.

Conversely, gas tankless water heaters often feature intricate heat exchangers and contingent fuel controls. These components not only add complexity to the overall system but also introduce a greater potential for breakdowns, which could shorten the service life of the unit if not properly maintained.

  • Electric tankless water heaters have fewer mechanic intricacies, which can aid in a lengthier service life.
  • Gas tankless water heaters, with more sophisticated components, may be predisposed to a shorter operational lifespan without regular maintenance.

We have observed that the need for ongoing upkeep in gas tankless water heaters could not only influence their longevity but may also imply additional costs over the unit's lifetime. It stands to reason that these factors merit consideration and reflect in the service life comparison between these two types of heaters.

Heater Type Complexity Maintenance Requirements Projected Service Life Electric Tankless Water Heaters Lower Minimal Longer Gas Tankless Water Heaters Higher Annual check-ups Shorter without maintenance

As leaders in the plumbing industry, we aim to deliver insights that empower our customers to make decisions that are both economically and practically sound. In terms of service life, electric tankless water heaters typically pose a more reliable choice for those seeking to maximize their investment over time. However, with diligent maintenance, gas tankless water heaters can serve a household well, especially where their high-flow capacities are in demand.

Maintenance and Operation: Ease of Use for Homeowners

Ensuring the longevity and efficiency of any home appliance often hinges on regular maintenance; this is particularly true when it comes to gas tankless water heater maintenance and electric tankless water heater maintenance. Understanding the maintenance needs for each can offer homeowners peace of mind and contribute to a more streamlined operation.

Maintenance Needs for Gas Tankless Water Heaters

Gas tankless water heaters demand vigilant maintenance to operate safely and efficiently. They operate with a combustion process that necessitates annual checks by trained technicians who perform safety inspections and detailed performance evaluations. These maintenance visits focus on verifying the integrity of the venting system, ensuring proper combustion and fuel connections, and cleaning critical components like the burner and heat exchanger.

  • Inspection of the venting system to prevent hazardous gas build-ups.
  • Checking for gas leaks and ensuring secure fuel line connections.
  • Assessment of the burner and heat exchanger for debris and proper function.
  • Verification of water and gas pressure to maintain operational standards.

Upkeep of Electric Tankless Water Heaters

In contrast, electric tankless water heaters are celebrated for their ease of maintenance, often only requiring the occasional cleaning of the inlet screen filter. This simple upkeep task prevents the accumulation of sediment and debris, which can impede water flow and heat transfer efficiency. Due to fewer mechanical parts, these systems forego the complex maintenance schedules of their gas counterparts.

  • Regularly cleaning the inlet screen filter to maintain water flow.
  • Checking system integrity and electrical connections as a precaution.
  • Periodic assessment by a professional is recommended, though less frequent than gas models.

Maintenance Task Gas Tankless Water Heater Electric Tankless Water Heater Annual Safety Inspections Required Not necessary Combustion Components Check Required N/A Inlet Screen Filter Cleaning Recommended Required Professional Maintenance Frequency Annually by trained technician As needed; less frequent Complexity of Maintenance High Low

By comparing the maintenance requirements of gas and electric tankless water heaters, it is evident that owners of electric models enjoy a less demanding schedule. However, regardless of the system you choose, aligning with rigorous maintenance standards is a sure way to enhance performance and extend the life of your tankless water heater. At the end of the day, ensuring regular gas tankless water heater maintenance and electric tankless water heater maintenance routines will keep your system functioning optimally and your home's hot water supply steady and reliable.

Gas vs Electric Tankless Water Heater Maintenance

Installation Requirements: Space, Ventilation, and Upgrades

When installing tankless water heaters, homeowners must navigate a series of requirements that ensure safe operation and optimal performance. The installation requisites for tankless water heaters cover a spectrum of considerations including the spatial layout of your home, ventilation needs, and possible system upgrades. In this section, we delve into the installation requirements for tankless water heaters, with a particular emphasis on the tankless water heater ventilation needs.

Gas tankless water heaters come with specific installation demands. These units require an exhaust system to vent the combustible gases generated during the heating process. The need for adequate ventilation cannot be overstated, as it is critical for both safety and regulatory compliance. Moreover, gas models may necessitate the upgrade of existing gas lines, ensuring they can handle the increased volume and pressure demands of a tankless system.

Conversely, we see a notable difference with electric tankless models. Owing to their emission-free operation, these heaters afford greater flexibility in terms of installation locations. Their compact size makes them suitable for smaller spaces, often fitting where gas models cannot, such as under sinks or in closets. This distinction is particularly beneficial for homes with limited available space or where venting may be impractical.

Let's consider the installation checklist for each tankless water heater type:

  • Gas Tankless Water Heater Installation:
  • Ensure proper venting is in place to safely expel exhaust gases.
  • Verify or upgrade gas lines to meet the heater's supply requirements.
  • Choose a location that allows for safe and accessible gas tankless water heater maintenance.
  • Electric Tankless Water Heater Installation:
  • Identify a suitable location that accommodates for the unit's compact size.
  • Assess electrical service capacity to meet the energy demands of the heater.
  • Consider proximity to points of use to maximize efficiency and minimize heat loss.

We must also account for the essential table showcasing the comparison of installation requirements for these two heater types:

Criteria Gas Tankless Water Heater Electric Tankless Water Heater Ventilation Requirements Exhaust venting is mandatory. No venting required. Spatial Flexibility Installation space must accommodate venting systems. Highly flexible with small footprint. Utility Upgrades Potential gas line upgrades for higher volume/pressure. May require electrical system enhancements to support amperage draw. Installation Complexity Higher complexity due to gas and venting considerations. Simpler, typically a less involved process. Regulatory Considerations Must conform to local building codes for gas safety and exhaust. Typically less stringent, focusing on electrical standards. Professional Expertise Needed Generally requires certified professionals for safe gas line and vent installation. Installation can often be managed by electricians without gas specialization.

Our aim is to provide homeowners with comprehensive knowledge on the installation requirements for tankless water heaters. Whether you're considering a gas or electric model, understanding the tankless water heater ventilation needs, space considerations, and potential upgrades is pivotal. By acquainting yourselves with these prerequisites, you can embark on installation with confidence, ensuring your tankless water heater functions safely and efficiently in your home.

Location and Climate Challenges for Water Heaters

When selecting a tankless water heater, a key factor often overlooked is the importance of tankless water heater location considerations. The climate where you live can play a significant role in determining the best choice for your household, impacting the overall climate impact on water heater performance. Let's explore how local climate conditions and energy source availability may influence your decision between an electric and gas tankless water heater.

Ambient Temperature and Incoming Water Heat

In regions with colder climates, the ambient temperature can drastically lower the incoming water temperature, requiring more energy to achieve the desired hot water output. In these cases, gas tankless water heaters, which generally offer greater flow rates and quicker heating response times compared to electric models, may be more-efficient despite their higher initial installation cost. However, areas with milder climates might not experience such a stark difference in performance between the two types of heaters, making electric tankless options more competitive and attractive due to their lower upfront cost and easier installation.

Accessibility of Energy Sources

Another consideration is the availability and stability of the local energy infrastructure, which can impact operational costs and the feasibility of installation. Areas with easy access to natural gas or propane might find gas tankless water heaters to be a logical solution, whereas regions with limited gas infrastructure or where electrical power is more economically priced would benefit from electric tankless water heaters.

Below, we present a table that captures the major factors affected by location and climate, and how they relate to the choice between gas and electric tankless water heaters.

ConsiderationElectric Tankless Water HeaterGas Tankless Water HeaterOptimal ClimateMild with stable electricityColder climate, demands higher heatingIncoming Water Temperature EffectHeating elements take longerQuicker response to cold waterEnergy Source AvailabilityElectrical infrastructure crucialAccessible natural gas/propane neededOperational CostsCan be lower where electricity is cheaperCan be lower where gas is cheaperInstallation FeasibilityEasier, often DIY friendlyMay require professional due to gas lines and venting

Lightning fast quotes.

Our water heater experts are standing by to help. Complete our form or call to schedule service.

Get a quoteA picture of a water heaters now technician.